It's still chilling, but so far it looks like it's turning out great. I followed the advice of several other reviewers and did the whole 2 cups of brown sugar, 3 cups of powdered sugar, and 1 cup of PB. Since I don't have a mixer I did it all by hand (I don't recommend it...). Took about 5 minutes of vigorous mixing to get all the clumps of powdered sugar mixed in and for it to become smooth. Tasted great off the spoon. ;) **UPDATE** Tasted great and was a hit! A bit sweet, but tasty! The PB flavor was not overpowering at all and it came out just like regular fudge. Thanks for the great recipe! I know what I'll be making this holiday seasoning for the gift baskets.

Turned out fine, but no one cared for the taste. I think it would taste better with white sugar than brown sugar.

Way too sweet for my (and my husband's) taste. I even decreased the amount of sugar I used- 2 cups brown sugar, 2 cups confectioner's sugar (that's all I had, thankfully), and I increased the PB to 1 cup. I give it two stars because my mom and brother liked them.

Turned out Good, except way too sweet! Next time I will use less Confectioners Sugar

This is the first time I've ever made fudge so I was not surprised when it turned out more like a goey mess that tasted like peanut butter!!! I'll have to keep working at it.

This was surprisingly good, and easy too. I decreased the brown sugar to 2 cups as suggested by another review. I also cooked the brown sugar, butter and milk in the microwave instead of on the stove. It worked perfectly, I just checked on it after 2 minutes and made sure it was at soft ball stage. I also added a half bag of mini marshmallows to the hot mixture before adding the powdered sugar...makes it a bit creamier I think. Altogether, a good peanut butter dessert!

Yummmmmmmmmmmmmmy. Thank you;)

This is great fudge! I have tried many recipes for peanut butter fudge over the years and without fail, they all turned out horribly. But that all changed with this recipe. It is easy and can be made with a few ingredients. I didn't have enough brown sugar and used about a half cup of granulated sugar and it was still great! I really recommend this fudge!

Not the creamiest, but due to the ease and ingredients always on hand, this is a winner. Not too peanut-buttery, either, which is a plus on some occasions.

I love this recipe!!! SOOOO easy (i followed the previous poster's advice of reducing some ingredients)!! also, i didn't have brown sugar, so i substituted Jif's Peanut Butter and Honey because i noticed it contained molasses and hoped it would work.....well, it definitely did! Next time I will try it with brown sugar and regular peanut butter to see if there is a big difference in taste. :)

Awesome! The Best. And awfully hard to kill. The recipe amounts are forgiving, you can experiment a little with flavour. It also works equally as well with ICING SUGAR as it does with ICING MIXTURE (added later: and caster sugar if niether are available!) . The MAIN TRICK is to not boil it too long. Soft ball (drop a little in a glass of water a soft ball will form) stage will give a lovely creamy consistency. If it gets too hot (boils too long) you may end up with dry pebbles as your sugar tries to head off to toffee land (I'm Australian if you're not sure what I mean). (addition:) Also, works as well with smooth, cruncy, sugar/salt free fresh smashed pb - whatever's yr thing. ENJOY

to: DEBMILLIKAN go to youtube and search for good eats fudge factor. everything about how to cook fudge. great show by the way.

I make this recipe exactly as is. I've been making it for over a year, always to rave reviews. It is very sweet, but that's just how I like it!

great recipe and very yummy and easy.especailly for us no so good cooks.thanks

This turned out wonderful despite my screwups! lol I did not have powder sugar, so I made my own. It still malts in your mouth, but tends to fall apart easy now that it's cool. I also used the 1-2-3 cup changes, and used extra crunchy peanut butter. Can't wait to make this again when better prepared!!!

I'm not sure what I did wrong but it didn't taste like the fudge I was use to! My chocolate definetly didn't swirl and the fat seperated from the peanut butter chips.

very good, just like my mother in laws.

OK to be honest i have just